Skip to main content
Blues Harmonica logo

User Account

Username:*
Password:*
Forgot Your Password?

Visitor Menu

  • Sign Up
  • Sample Lesson #1
  • Sample Lesson #2
  • Student Recordings
  • Forums
Forums :: Ask Instructor David Barrett

Another HARP Teacher writes and plays different....I'm confused

2 replies [Last post]
Thu, 04/20/2017 - 17:35
DNullman
DNullman's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/07/2017

David:   I’m practicing LOA 5 My Blues and it’s actually beginning to sound like music.   Your lessons are great, challenging, and progressive.  I bought a lesson (on the net) from Sandy Weltman, a great player.  His TAB notation is different than yours, so I spent half a day re-writing it in “Barrett TAB”.   His TAB also doesn’t relate to TIME, nor to NOTES, merely holes.  First, why doesn’t everyone use the same TAB??  Your TAB is great!!!   Easy to understand, accurate, note related, and shows time, expression, dynamics, and more.   Second,  it seems that he strictly puckers, so, obviously gives up slaps, pulls, and lots of stuff.   His first lick (translated to Barrett format), for example, 2   3’   4+    4’   4   5   4   4’   4+   3’   4+   3’   2   2”   1   1+   1   2  (a “Paul Butterfield type lick)  is nearly impossible to play tongue blocked (he plays it very, very, fast by the way).  He also (obviously) leaves out all the great slaps, and techniques that enhance my playing.  It sounds great when Sandy plays it, but without all the TAB details that you put in, I don’t know how to learn it.   I hate to merely forget about other teachers because they may have lots for me to learn from, but honestly, your stuff is great!!!   I just want to expand my scope of listening and learning.   What’s your thoughts on this?

Top
Thu, 04/20/2017 - 17:52
#1
David Barrett
David Barrett's picture
Offline
ExpertHead InstructorTeacher 10Level 10
Joined: 12/20/2009
Hello DNullman. I'm glad you

Hello DNullman. I'm glad you like my approach and notation. Unfortunately harmonica TAB is not standardized... nothing we can do about it... just one of the pains we have to deal with. In regards to pucker... that lick can most definitely be played in a tongue block. There is no difference in speed between any embouchure... tongue block, pucker or U-block... you can play them all equally as fast. So, in this case, you just need (as in all challenging music) to slow it down until you can get up to his speed.

Top
Thu, 04/20/2017 - 19:01
#2
DNullman
DNullman's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/07/2017
I'm glad you....

Thanks David...... now i've got to stay up all night practicing :)

Top

Sign me up!

Full access to all lessons starts at $20/month! (with annual subscription)

Subscribe

Free Sample Lessons

After watching the BluesHarmonica.com overview video, try one of the lessons below to experience a lesson at BluesHarmonica.com.

  • Tongue Blocking Study 2 – This study is for the newer player or the player new to tongue blocking
  • Bending Study 5 – This is for the advanced player looking to improve their bending skills

Contributors

  • Aki Kumar
  • Joe Tartaglia
  • Gary Smith
  • Mark Hummel
  • Joe Filisko

Site Links

  • About David Barrett
  • Accredited Instructors
  • Links
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us
Hohner
© 2009 - 2025 David Barrett and the Harmonica Masterclass Co. for Bluesharmonica.com