Tongue Blocking Issue Moving Down The Scale
I'm a beginner and just started working on my scale.. going up (from 4 to 6) I can get pretty clean notes probably 80% of the time... but when I move back down the scale, I keep bleeding into multiple notes? Not sure if my tongue is coming off the comb or my mouth is opening up more? any suggestions on what to look for/concentrate on when moving down scale?
Back in the late 1900s my dad tried to teach me Harmonica. I could not get it, but learned to play the trumpet instead! Anyway, now at age 5Old man I got intrested again. My dad was able to teach me a V tonge technique, so I can play single notes simi OK. However I want to work and get realy GOOD. I just started playing two days ago. When playing the scale with 11:00 tonque block starting at hole 4, I find I can do MUCH better with my tounge to the Right at 1:00. I have a better seal, and the whole things just seems to be more natural, up, as well as down. My question is this.... Is Tounge blocking on Right a bad habit? It seems that most of the time we will play hole 1 to 8 anyway, so this seems like a good idea. However, because I am just starting out, I do not know if this will cause problems with more advanced lessons. Right now I am still on Lesson 1, week 1.
At the moment I find myself going back and forth to V block, Tongue to right (1:00), and forcing myself to Tongue block left (11:00). I know from playing the trumpet, begining habbits are HARD to break.
Please advise
The V, or U-block as it's commonly known, is an embouchure used by some really great players, but for many essential techniques, tongue blocking is more versatile. Some folks use U-blocking for single notes, and switch to tongue blocking when they need it for specific techniques and effects.
I'm not sure what you mean by 11:00 and 1:00, but I'll try to explain some of the basics.
To directly answer your main question, though, most single-note tongue blocking is done with the hole played through an opening in the right corner of your mouth, with the tongue blocking the holes to the left. This lets you lift your tongue off to add lower pitched notes to the single note (assuming you're holding the harp right side up wtih Hole 1 on the left; some folks do hold it upside down, which is fine.)
If your single note is on the left side of your tongue, you will sound *higher* notes when you lift it off. This is an interesting effect (I use it sometimes) but it is very rarely used; I'm not sure I've ever heard it on a blues record.
As to applying your tongue to the harp when tongue blocking, don't angle it to the right or left. Advance the tongue directly forward to touch the face of the harmonica. You can apply the tip directly to the holes, tuck the tip under the holes and press the broad surface of the tongue to the holes or even angle the tip up and use the underside of the tongue (I do the latter to block just one hole with the holes on either side open).
Thank you for the quick reply!
So I will work to master keeping my tounge to the left (11:00), blocking the three holes on the left, and playing the single hole to the right. However, this does seem wierd when trying to play hole 1 or 2. I assume this will feel more natural over time.
(About the 11:00, and 1:00 position. I was referering to the first few "Sharon Barrett" lesson videos whrn Tounge blocking was explained to her. Keep the toung left (11:00) or Right, (1:00) with 12:00 being straight ahead.)
The more I study this craft, I find there seems to be a MULTITUDE of variations that can be used sucessfully, unlike the dicipline of the trumpet. I find this facinating in it's self. I just want to make sure I don't start any "bad", poor or less than optimal habits.
Again, thank you! I now know to keep my tounge to my left! (Cool tip about using the bottom of the Tounge!)
Assuming that the opening in your mouth is in the right corner of your mouth and on the right side of your tongue:
When you move up the hole numbers, the harmonica is moving to the left in your mouth and:
When you move down the hole numbers, the harmonica is moving to the right in your mouth and:
It's also possible that you're relaxing or enlarging the opening as you move from hole to hole and then re-establishing your embouchure when you land on the target hole; beginning players often do theis unconsciously.
Try this.
Working this exercise isolates the hole changes, without the complication of breath changes. If the moves down the hole numbers are still not clean (i.e., all notes are not isolated single notes), work on this. The main thing to go for is no change in the size and shape of your embouchure. This involves two main elements:
If you can make the moves above cleanly, then try it with the scale.
If the problem returns when you play the scale, pay attention to what happens when you change both btreath direction (blow/draw or draw'blow) and hole. You may be unconsciously changing your mouth opening.
Hope this helps. let me know how it goes.