Why use tongue switch between holes 1 and 2?
Isn't easier, to play hole 1, just push the harmonica more to the right ?
I'm a beginer (just started level 5) and I was wondering if there some reason or advantage to use tongue switch (put my tongue to the right to play hole 1), because it seems to be more dificult than just let my tongue in the left and push harmonica more to the right.
I am learning to play "My Blues Bending Song Example #4" and the in first two bars gets a little complicated to do a bend on 2 and go tongue switch to play hole 1. So I would like to know: do I keep training this tongue switch or I may just puch the harmonica more to the right ?
Thanks!
There are three approaches to Holes 1 and 2:
- Tongue block with the right corner open all the way down to 1.
- Switch to pucker for 1 and 2.
- Corner switch to the left corner for 1 and maybe 2.
I do all three, depending on what I'm up to:
- Tongue blocking out of the right corner all the way down, unless I have a reason not to.
- Pucker to play a Hole 1 overblow or a fast diddle-diddle-typ articulation, which uses the tip of the tongue on the roof of the mouth.
- Corner switch if I'm about to make a quick upward leap of several holes, or open a split, hammer, or rake with Hole 1 or 2 on the left side of that action.
I tongue block with the tongue blocking to the right for holes 1-3, and with the tongue blocking to the left for holes 4-10. So I basically tongue switch at hole 3. I like switching TB at hole 3 rather than hole 1 because I balance out using both sides of my throat and my lips never veer too close to the edge of the Harp so it’s all much more comfortable. On a side note, I also prefer to use the underside of my tongue to tongue-block because it allows me to get a pucker-like ”trumpet sound” to my notes as my tongue can reach the roof of my mouth to give the note a bit of definition when wanted. Not as much as I would get when I used to pucker (yet) and I can’t do the diddly-doo trick, but it’s something. I‘m also a 100% tongue-blocker for all holes, including all bends. It’s nice for me to keep it simple and not have to switch between pucker and TB. My 2 cents!
When you get to level 7 you'll look back at how simple that riff is. Learning to tongue block bend is part of the progression. Keep on with it.
Good luck.......Mike